
Last Updated on November 19, 2026 9:17 am
RALEIGH, N.C. — A state audit review of the emergency radio system first responders relied on during Hurricane Helene found that 12 of its tower sites were damaged in the storm, including sites in Watauga, Ashe and Avery counties.
The N.C. Office of the State Auditor released the Rapid Response Special Report on Monday, Nov. 16. It examined why the Voice Interoperability Plan for Emergency Responders, known as VIPER, had communication disruptions during and after the storm. The statewide mobile radio system is managed by the N.C. State Highway Patrol.
High Country sites
According to outage data the Highway Patrol gave auditors, the 12 damaged sites included three in the High Country:
- Watauga: 97 hours and 45 minutes of downtime. The site stayed operational for local communication, but wind damaged its microwave dishes.
- Ashe: 3 hours and 34 minutes, non-operational, because of a generator water pump failure.
- Avery: 2 hours and 30 minutes, non-operational, because of a generator water pump failure.
Across the state, five of the damaged sites were completely non-operational. The other seven went into “site trunking,” in which a tower works for local radios but cannot connect to other sites. The Highway Patrol cited four main causes: generator problems, cascading microwave outages, wind damage to microwave dishes, and uninterruptible power supply failures. Repairs to damaged towers had cost about $2.1 million at the time of the report, with an estimated $1.2 million still needed for one site.
What auditors found
- A third-party after-action review by the McChrystal Group found a “complete communications blackout” exposed weaknesses in the VIPER backup system, including insufficient integration of satellite-based alternatives.
- Several county emergency managers reported delays of more than an hour when trying to share or request information over VIPER.
- In the western part of the state, 172,926 of 2,929,944 calls (5.9%) returned a busy signal between Sept. 23 and Oct. 9, 2024. The Highway Patrol says the system’s normal busy rate is under 0.03%.
- Only 45 of North Carolina’s 100 counties use VIPER as their primary radio system for emergency response.
The auditor recommended further work to evaluate whether VIPER remains the most cost-effective network for disaster response. That would include comparing land-based systems with satellite technology and looking at ways to prevent overloading.
Funding
The Highway Patrol has asked the General Assembly for more operations and maintenance money, saying it is needed to keep the system ready and fix outages quickly. The report says the patrol has requested about $70 million in recurring and one-time funds since the 2022 fiscal year. In October 2025, lawmakers approved a permanent $2.1 million annual increase, the first recurring increase since 2016.
Highway Patrol response
In a Sept. 26 response included in the report, Highway Patrol Commander Freddy L. Johnson Jr. said satellite integration was “physically impossible” when Helene hit because VIPER used older microwave transport equipment, and that funding and contracting delays slowed the upgrade. The patrol said it believes the reported hour-long delays were due to user error and system overloading, and said VIPER “remained online throughout the storm” and was the most used communications medium for responding agencies.
The patrol said it is adding radio training modules for users, inspecting towers and adding stiffer mounts to microwave antennas, and said staffing and funding limits prevent regular generator maintenance. It opposes user fees and supports a proposal, House Bill 695, that would direct part of the 911 tax to VIPER.
The report is available on the State Auditor’s website.

















